The Case of
If you were an atheist
you would say to me, "God does not exist"
and if God never existed ,
then God would not have promised to Abraham anything.
Whether God would have promised the Land of Canaan(Palestine)
or actually promised only the Coming of the Messiah..... ....
in those both cases , there would not be a Promise
because there were no God, according to the Atheists.
Therefore there was no promised Land of Canaan
nor there should consequently be any State of Israel,
That is easy ,
and this case is closed .
On the other hand, if you are a believer,
whether a Muslim or a Christian or a Jew ,
I still would have three questions for you :
Did God Promise a Piece of Land ??
or did God promise the Coming of the Messiah ??
Either , or !! Define and identify please that Promise.
When we know that once upon a time there was a Jewish-Kingdom
on some part of the Land of Palestine and it was only temporarily , of course!
and we equally know and believe that the Messiah did come
so therefore the Promise was once fulfilled ,
whether this Promise were the Land or the Messiah....it did happen !!
Unless it were an endless,continuous and a renewable promise
this promise was already..... .....consumed.
(unless the Messiah should have to come eight times)
The so called "chosen" people were an Iraqi-Chaldean- Tribe
from the city of Ur.......anyone else is an impostor
or it is today, a case of mistaken identity .
If you are an Atheist you should not believe in
nor support the State of Israel
if you are a believer you should decide first who
or what was promised ? the Land or the Messiah ??
if it were the Land , then it has been given once already to Abraham
and if it were the Messiah , well .....he did come 2000 years ago !!
Again .....Case closed !!!
If you were an Atheist or a Believer,note please that
the State of Israel has nothing to do with any religion,
not even the Judaism.
not at all......... . the Devil's Lawyer